Is the Wine Society evil?

dr-strangelove_00337070Of course it isn’t! For a start they don’t have a Dr Strangelove-style war room in Stevenage with a world map covering in blinking lights. But if I was an independent wine merchant I wouldn’t be too happy with this institution. The Wine Society has an advantage over most other merchants for two reasons: 1) it has massive buying power being the second (or it might be the third) biggest mail order wine company in the country after Direct Wines (Laithwaite’s et al); 2) it’s a mutual society owned by its members so it doesn’t have to make a profit for shareholders. All the money is ploughed back into the society. In the £6-15 bracket, it cannot be beaten on price. Unlike other wine businesses with huge buying power such as supermarkets and Majestic, it does not discount so the price you see is the best price. I lose track of the number of times I’ve spoken to a wine merchant who has sighed wearily when I’ve pointed out how the Wine Society does it for £2 cheaper.

Where the Wine Society differs from other big institutions, Tesco’s, BBC, Amazon, who make it hard for smaller players is its lack of ambition. Whereas one imagines that Amazon does have a war room with each blinking light representing a bookshop to be snuffed out, the Wine Society are not planning to sell every bottle of wine in the UK and then Ireland and then Europe. They’re expanding very slowly. Nevertheless they do undoubtedly take business from smaller merchants and if I was a wine merchant I would avoid stocking anything that the Wine Society also stocks. As a wine writer whose readers are interested in value – I’ve been told off by the editor of the Lady for recommending anything too expensive – it’s often very hard not to write about them. It doesn’t help matters that their PR people are so good, their staff so nice and don’t get me started on the vast sums they pay me to write for their newsletter. Because of this temptation to stick with what I know, I make a conscious effort to sniff out interesting wine from small merchants. Not out of any patronising notion that I should support indies but because it keeps the column interesting. The reason I don’t feature many wines from supermarkets is not because they are big but because they’re not very interesting to write about.

One merchant, Red Squirrel Wines, has gone further and thinks that writers should not feature wines from the Society at all because it is a club. He likens a wine columnist featuring the Wine Society to a restaurant critic writing about Annabel’s. It’s a funny comparison but doesn’t really bear a closer look. To join Annabel’s you need a proposer, a seconder and then your membership application is put before a committee. You also need to pay £1000 to join and £1000 a year thereafter. Anyone can join the Wine Society for £40, you don’t even need a friend to propose you. If you’re interested in wine, then it’s not a big outlay. By Mr Red Squirrel’s logic, a television reviewer shouldn’t write about programs on Sky as you need to subscribe in order to watch them. 

Even if the Wine Society was as exclusive as Annabel’s, I might still like to read about it. I read restaurant reviews of places that my only chance of getting a table would be to sleep with the maitre d’ – and be really good.  I read Jancis Robinson’s vertical tasting of Sassicaia. I watch Jeremy Clarkson driving very expensive cars very very fast. I read about lots of things that I cannot or have no intention of sampling. One of the reasons that wine columns can be dull is that they’re perceived as shopping lists rather than entertainment.

About Henry

I’m a drinks writer. My day job is features editor at the Master of Malt blog. I also contribute to BBC Good Food, the Spectator and others. You can read some of my work here. I’ve done a bit of radio, given some talks and written a couple of books (Empire of Booze, The Home Bar and the forthcoming Cocktail Dictionary).
This entry was posted in Restaurants, Wine articles and tagged , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Is the Wine Society evil?

  1. shameclub says:

    I’ve just inherited a Wine Society membership – a feature I think is very endearing, old school and rather clever. I will always think of my father when drinking Wine Society wine. Or anything for that matter… But anyway having just inherited I was glad that the Wine Society didn’t turn out to be seriously evil. I’d have to take your word for it but find it a bit grim when previously delightful things such as googling or lighting Chinese lanterns turn out to be dangerously evil. Like that time north London caused a global shortage of quinoa – nightmare!

  2. Having noted the “war room” imagery at the top of the page I’m compelled to ask: what do you think Dr. Strangelove would drink? A big Mosel? Kirsch? Lone Star beer? One must know…

  3. I think Mosel might be too delicate for him. Kirsch would be just his sort of thing though my guess would be Kummel.

  4. I’m sure the Wine Society (TWS) isn’t evil. In fact, I have often wished I were a member – and do occasionally share in purchases with friends who are members. But as an independent merchant myself, I am constantly vexed by their pricing policy – especially on a handful of wines that I have bought from one or two of their agent suppliers. Most recently, I was one of the first (and certainly before TWS) to list a couple of new French discoveries from a certain agent, only to find later on down the line that TWS were selling those exact same wines for not much more than I could buy them for! Suffice to say that I will now be giving that agent (and any other that supplies TWS) a wide berth. On the plus side, at least they haven’t – thus far – nicked any of the growers I have put so much effort into discovering and introducing to the UK market. Unlike various other independents I could mention. In short, some of us lead, whereas others just follow. 🙂

  5. Pingback: Budget bargains from the Wine Society part one | Henry's World of Booze

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s